President Trump routinely passes along false and misleading
information that has been circulating online. Today, he appeared to be
the one starting it.
Shortly before Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg died, she made a request about
what should happen to her seat on the Supreme Court. “My most fervent wish is
that I will not be replaced until a new president is installed,” Ms. Ginsburg
said, according to NPR, which reported that the 87-year-old justice dictated
the note to her granddaughter, Clara Spera, in the final days of her life.
But during a “Fox & Friends” interview on Monday morning, President
Trump claimed, without evidence, that Justice Ginsburg’s “dying wish” might
actually have been written by a top Democrat like Representative Adam Schiff of
California, Senator Chuck Schumer of New York or Speaker Nancy Pelosi of
California. “I don’t know that she said that, or if that was written out by
Adam Schiff, and Schumer and Pelosi,” Mr. Trump said. “That came out of the
wind. It sounds so beautiful, but that sounds like a Schumer deal, or maybe
Pelosi or Shifty Schiff.”
This baseless claim appears to be a Trump original. Questions about
the legitimacy of Ms. Ginsburg’s “dying wish” were not circulating online in
any significant way before his Fox News appearance.
But after the appearance, social media has filled with false claims echoing
Mr. Trump’s conspiracy theory, and taking it even further into the land of
nonsense. On Twitter, users continued to spread their false claims that Ms.
Ginsburg dictated the note to her “8-year-old granddaughter.” (Ms. Spera is a
lawyer who graduated from Harvard Law School in 2017.) They have cast doubts on
the integrity of NPR’s reporting. (Nina Totenberg, the NPR reporter who published
the detail about Ms. Ginsburg’s last wish, is a longtime Supreme Court reporter
who has been close to the Ginsburg family for decades.) And they have sought to
portray Democrats spreading false rumors about Ms. Ginsburg’s death as part of
a political power grab.
In an appearance on MSNBC on Monday, Ms. Totenberg confirmed her account of
Ms. Ginsburg’s statement, and said that others in the room at the time
witnessed her making it, including her doctor. “I checked,” Ms. Totenberg
added, “because I’m a reporter.”
Mr. Schiff, one of the congressional Democrats Mr. Trump speculated might
have invented Justice Ginsburg’s request, responded on Twitter, saying “Mr.
President, this is low. Even for you.”